Walk into any contract electronics finisher and you’ll find a shop full of engineers with strong opinions about finishes. Some love hot air solder leveling; some like organic solderability preservatives – but when it comes down to reliability, it always comes back to immersion gold.
It’s nothing new, but it’s nothing old, either. It’s been around for decades upon decades in applications where failure is not an option. Why do aerospace contractors, medical finishers and high-end contract assemblers continue to specify it despite the premium? Because it works. The chemistry is predictable and performance characteristics solve problems that lower-cost alternatives cannot.
The Chemistry Behind It
Here’s what actually happens when it comes to immersion gold. You have exposed copper; onto this goes a layer of nickel. Yes – nickel – this is the barrier layer. Then, you have gold – but not through electricity as with typical plating.
Instead, the gold displaces itself onto the nickel thanks to a chemical reaction. It’s a self-limiting reaction. This means that it plates a thin, uniformly-imperceptible layer of gold and stops. You end up with 2-4 microinches of gold over about 120-240 microinches of gold.
Yes, this sounds complex but it’s more easily controlled than electroplating. You don’t have to worry about current distribution and even geometry; the chemical process displaces itself uniformly across complicated parts and tight spots.
Why Electronics Manufacturers Continue to Choose It
The reliability aspect is huge. For avionics and medical circuit boards, the finish needs to remain solderable for months or years. Immersion gold does not oxidize like plain copper does. That gold – even if it’s ultra-thin – creates a hermetic seal that keeps oxygen from getting beneath it.
But better yet, the finish possesses incredible wire bonding characteristics. For those in semiconductor packaging or hybrid circuits needing fine-pitch wire bonding, immersion gold gives a surface that bonds consistently well. The gold is pure enough not to form intermetallic compounds that jeopardize bond performance.
Solderability is another reason it continues to get specified. The finish wets well when solder meets it in assembly. This is more important than people believe. In high-volume production, all joints should form correctly on first pass – rework is time-consuming and costly; for some applications, it isn’t even allowed. Immersion gold has that first-pass reliability.
The Cost Question Everyone Asks
No one says the finish is inexpensive. Gold isn’t cheap and neither is the process related to it by way of careful chemistry and addition. Immersion gold costs anywhere from three to five times the cost of organic options – and often more depending on how in depth the job is.
What people don’t expect is that the cost isn’t necessarily from the immersion in gold itself. The nickel underlayer creates its own processing needs and applications; the gold bath requires constant monitoring and replenishment; labs that do this well are constantly testing for thickness and contamination and maintaining tight quality checks.
So when does the price make sense? For consumer electronics that have a one-year lifespan? Probably not. For anything that needs longevity, multiple thermal cycles or guaranteed reliability? Definitely. The cost of field failure in a medical device or aircraft component trumps any cost associated with the finish.
Where It Shows Up Most Often
The medical device world is a huge proponent of this finish. Implantable electronics, patient monitoring devices, diagnostic equipment – these are frequently specified for immersion gold. Biocompatibility matters with electronics as do irreproachable failure statuses.
So too do aerospace and defense applications look favorably upon immersion gold. Avionics need to operate in temperature extremes, high-vibration situations – and they need to survive for twenty or thirty years. No component in a plane’s flight control system is getting replaced every few years for it functions like a phone.
High-frequency RF and microwave circuits find success, too; because of gold’s electrical properties at high frequencies, this finish does not pose signal loss capabilities like some other finishes can provide. Immersion gold shields radar systems, satellite communications and test equipment.
The Black Pad Problem
However, black pad syndrome exists as an unfortunate failure mode associated with immersion gold. Black pad syndrome occurs when the nickel gets corroded during the gold immersion process, resulting in a weakened interface that looks great but catastrophically fails when it comes to soldering or wire bonding.
The biggest problem? Sometimes you can’t see it coming. The board passes visual inspection and fails in the field without remorse. This means process control is key; shops which consistently produce good immersion gold are actively pH monitoring their solutions.
Temperature control counts, too; run the gold bath too hot and you accelerate nickel corrosion; run it too cold and you get poor coverage or rough deposits; the window isn’t great for success which means it’s not such an easy metal finishing process for everyone.
What Separates Good Work from Mediocre Results
Certifications mean something in terms of what someone can do with immersion gold – but it’s not all there is to it. The best places measure thickness often on every lot as opposed to just periodic inspections; they’re measuring bath chemistry day-in and day-out and replacing solutions before contamination occurs.
Equipment matters more than you think; older immersion gold lines may not have the temperature stability or agitation control needed to successfully complete jobs on complex boards with various feature sizes; modern equipment has better monitoring that helps catch problems before they become scrap.
Experience counts, too; places have seen it all if they’ve been doing this for years and know how things fail; they know how various substrate types act and how high density interconnects should be processed – and if they should be processed at all.
The Reality of Using This Finish
If you’re specifying this finish for the first time, understand that it will need tighter tolerances on incoming work; surfaces must be prepared correctly; any type of contamination or oxide layer present on copper will create adhesion issues; nickel will also not plate correctly – and defects will occur.
Expect longer lead times, too, especially with aerospace or medical applications where testing and certification exist. Rush jobs are available – but expensive – and can create problems with quality.
But ultimately – when you need what’s needed with this finish – there’s no comparable substitute. Solderability, wire bondability, corrosion resistance, shelf life – it’s a performance characteristic like none other – and that’s why engineers continue to specify it based off field results over decades!
For more, visit Pure Magazine