Dual citizenship is often sold as a perfect safety net—two passports, more freedom, and a built-in “Plan B.” But beneath the marketing, dual nationality can introduce legal, financial, and personal risks that many people only discover after committing.
Search interest in why dual citizenship is bad has risen sharply as governments expand tax enforcement, banks tighten compliance rules, and military obligations re-enter public debate. What once felt like a quiet administrative advantage is now a status with real consequences—especially for U.S. citizens and their families.
This guide does not argue that dual citizenship is always a mistake. Instead, it explains when and why dual citizenship can become a liability, not an asset. You’ll learn about taxation, banking restrictions, military service, consular protection limits, and 2025–2026 policy risks—so you can make an informed decision before problems arise.
The Core Problem With Dual Citizenship
Dual citizenship becomes problematic when two countries assert overlapping authority over the same person.
When governments don’t fully coordinate, dual citizens can face:
- Conflicting legal obligations
- Competing tax rules
- Reduced diplomatic protection
- Duties that cannot be declined or delegated
The issue isn’t holding two passports—it’s managing two sovereign legal systems at once.
Major Disadvantages of Dual Citizenship
Double Taxation and Compliance Burdens (Especially for U.S. Citizens)
The United States is one of the few countries that taxes based on citizenship rather than residence, a principle upheld by longstanding legal precedent. This means U.S. citizens may owe U.S. taxes even if they live permanently abroad.
While tax treaties and Totalization Agreements often reduce actual double taxation, they do not eliminate compliance. Dual citizens may still face:
- FATCA compliance requirements
- FBAR reporting for foreign bank accounts
- Complex filing for foreign income
- Exposure to PFIC rules on non-U.S. investment funds
Even when no additional tax is owed, compliance costs can be substantial.
Banking “De-Risking” for U.S. Persons (2025–2026 Reality)
An increasingly common issue for dual citizens is restricted access to banking.
Many European and Asian banks now refuse to open—or actively close—accounts held by individuals classified as “U.S. Persons.” This is not ideological; it’s financial. FATCA reporting imposes ongoing compliance costs that many foreign institutions no longer wish to absorb.
As a result, some dual citizens experience:
- Sudden account closures
- Inability to open local investment accounts
- Limited access to mortgages or financial products
This trend accelerated after 2024 and remains a major friction point in 2026.
Mandatory Military Service Obligations
Several countries enforce compulsory military or national service, which can apply to dual nationals, depending on age, residency, and registration status.
Examples include:
- South Korea (approximately 18–21 months)
- Israel (mandatory service for most citizens)
- Turkey (with limited buy-out options)
Some European countries, including Germany and Serbia, have actively debated or revived service frameworks since 2025. While enforcement varies, dual citizenship does not automatically exempt individuals from these obligations.
Also Read: What Is a Common Law Partner? Rights in the UK, Canada & US
Limited Consular Protection Abroad
Under international law’s Master Nationality Rule, when you are inside a country of which you are a citizen, that country is not required to recognize your other nationality.
In practice:
- A dual citizen arrested in their second country cannot rely on foreign embassy intervention
- Diplomatic assistance may be unavailable in legal disputes
- Evacuation or emergency protections can be limited
This is a common misunderstanding among new dual citizens.
Conflicting Laws and Legal Exposure
Some countries:
- Do not fully recognize dual nationality
- Apply local law regardless of foreign status
- Restrict property ownership or inheritance rights
Dual citizens may face unexpected consequences related to:
- Business ownership
- Estate planning
- Criminal or civil liability
Legal conflicts are often situational, but when they arise, resolution options are limited.
Travel and Passport Restrictions
Many countries legally require citizens to:
- Enter and exit using that country’s passport
- Comply with local travel restrictions during emergencies
In rare cases—usually tied to military service or national mobilization—exit permissions may be delayed. This is not typical, but it is possible in certain jurisdictions.
When Dual Citizenship Is Actually a Bad Idea (Risk Framework)
Dual citizenship is more likely to create problems if you fall into one of these categories:
| Situation | Risk Level |
|---|---|
| U.S. citizen living abroad | High |
| Subject to compulsory military service | High |
| Business owner with foreign income | Medium–High |
| Dependent on consular protection | Medium |
| Citizenship in a non-recognizing country | High |
This framework explains why experiences vary so widely.
When Dual Citizenship Is Not a Problem
Dual citizenship often works smoothly when:
- Both countries recognize dual nationality
- Neither taxes based on citizenship
- No military service obligation exists
- Financial activity is simple and local
For example, EU–EU dual citizenship typically involves far fewer conflicts than U.S.–non–U.S. pairings. The risk lies less in the concept itself and more in which countries are involved.
Also Check: Understanding the Apostille UK Process: A Comprehensive Guide
Real-World Examples
Example 1:
A U.S.–EU dual citizen lost access to local banking after being flagged as a U.S. Person under FATCA reporting rules.
Example 2:
A dual national faced unexpected military service requirements after returning to their second country for long-term residence.
These outcomes are not universal—but they are increasingly reported.
Common Myths About Dual Citizenship
- ❌ “You can choose which laws apply”
- ❌ “Tax treaties cancel all obligations.”
- ❌ “You can ignore one passport if it’s inconvenient.”
In reality, governments decide how citizenship is enforced—not individuals.
Pros vs Cons of Dual Citizenship (Quick Comparison)
| Aspect | Advantage | Disadvantage |
|---|---|---|
| Travel | Expanded access | Entry/exit rules |
| Taxes | Planning opportunities | Reporting burden |
| Rights | Broader eligibility | Conflicting duties |
| Security | Backup nationality | Legal exposure |
2025–2026 Trends That Increase Risk
- Expanded global tax data sharing (CRS + FATCA)
- Increased banking compliance enforcement
- Renewed military service debates
- Greater scrutiny of cross-border citizens
In December 2025, a proposal known as the Exclusive Citizenship Act was introduced in the U.S. Senate. While its passage remains uncertain, its existence reflects renewed political attention on dual nationality—something dual citizens should monitor going forward.
Renouncing Citizenship Is Not Simple—or Cheap
For those who later decide dual citizenship isn’t worth the burden, exiting can be costly. Renouncing U.S. citizenship currently involves a $2,350 administrative fee, and for certain high-net-worth individuals, an exit tax may apply.
Dual citizenship is often far easier to acquire than to reverse.
FAQs
Q1. Is there any downside to having dual citizenship?
Yes. Dual citizenship can create tax compliance challenges, potential mandatory military obligations, banking restrictions, and limited consular protection in certain countries. These risks vary depending on the countries involved.
Q2. Do dual citizens have to pay taxes in both countries?
Sometimes. For example, U.S. citizens are taxed on worldwide income, regardless of where they live. Tax treaties may reduce double taxation, but reporting requirements like FATCA and FBAR still apply.
Q3. Does dual citizenship affect Social Security benefits?
It can. Countries with Totalization Agreements coordinate Social Security or retirement benefits to prevent gaps or double contributions. Your benefit may depend on work history in both countries.
Q4. Is dual citizenship worth it?
It depends. The value of dual citizenship varies based on the combination of countries, income sources, legal obligations, and personal lifestyle. Dual citizenship may be beneficial for travel or family, but the risks should be weighed carefully.
Q5. Why do some countries not allow dual citizenship?
Many countries restrict dual citizenship for reasons including legal clarity, national security, and ensuring loyalty to a single nation. For example, countries like China, Austria, and Japan generally require renunciation of prior citizenship.
Conclusion
Dual citizenship is neither a universal benefit nor a universal mistake—but it is not neutral. For some people, the downsides emerge slowly through taxes, banking restrictions, legal obligations, or reduced protections.
Understanding why dual citizenship can be bad in certain situations allows you to assess whether the benefits genuinely apply to your life—or simply look appealing in theory. The key isn’t fear, but clarity.
Related: Ultimate Guide to Portugal D2 Entrepreneur Visa for Business Owners & Startups
