Buying a used car in the UK always involves a degree of risk, but one of the most powerful tools available to reduce that risk is an MOT check. While many buyers look only at whether a vehicle has passed or failed, the real value lies in understanding why it failed and whether those failures are deal-breakers.
Not all MOT failures are equal. Some are inexpensive, routine fixes, while others point to deeper safety, structural, or maintenance issues. Knowing the difference between major and minor MOT fails can save you thousands of pounds and help you avoid buying a problematic vehicle.
Understanding MOT failure categories through an MOT check
An MOT check records defects under specific categories that determine how serious an issue is. These categories are essential for buyers to understand before committing to a purchase.
Minor defects are issues that do not pose an immediate safety risk. The car can still pass the MOT, but repairs are recommended.
Major defects are more serious problems that affect safety or the environment. A car with major defects automatically fails the MOT and cannot legally be driven until repaired.
There is also a dangerous category, which represents immediate risk. Vehicles with dangerous defects should not be driven at all.
When reviewing an MOT check, it’s important to look beyond the pass/fail status and examine how frequently these defects appear and whether they reoccur year after year.
Minor MOT fails: When they’re usually not a deal-breaker
Minor MOT failures are extremely common and, on their own, should not necessarily stop you buying a car. In many cases, they are signs of normal wear and tear.
Common minor defects include:
- Worn but legal tyres
- Slight brake pad wear
- Failing windscreen wipers
- Weak number plate illumination
- Minor suspension wear noted as advisory
If an MOT check shows only minor issues, especially on an older vehicle, this often indicates honest use rather than neglect. These repairs are usually inexpensive and easy to fix.
However, buyers should pay attention to patterns. If the same minor advisories appear across multiple MOTs, it may suggest the owner repeatedly ignored maintenance rather than addressing problems early. While not a deal-breaker, this can be used as leverage during price negotiation.
Major MOT fails that should make you walk away
Some major MOT failures should immediately raise red flags. These are the types of defects that often indicate costly repairs or long-term reliability issues.
Major failures that should make you reconsider include:
- Structural corrosion to chassis, subframes, or load-bearing areas
- Brake system failures, such as leaking brake lines or imbalanced braking
- Severe suspension faults, including broken springs or worn control arms
- Steering defects, such as excessive play or damaged steering components
- Airbag or seatbelt failures, which compromise occupant safety
An MOT check revealing recent or repeated major failures in these areas often means the vehicle has been poorly maintained or driven hard. Even if the seller claims repairs were completed, buyers should be cautious especially if proof is limited.
In many cases, walking away from a car with multiple major MOT fails is the safest and most cost-effective decision.
Why a clean MOT doesn’t guarantee a healthy car
A recently passed MOT can create a false sense of security, especially for buyers who don’t review the full MOT check history. While a fresh pass may look reassuring, it doesn’t always mean the vehicle is genuinely problem-free.
Some sellers time MOT tests strategically, repairing only the minimum required to secure a pass. In these cases, earlier advisories or major defects may have been temporarily patched rather than properly fixed. A detailed MOT check helps uncover whether serious issues were repeatedly flagged in previous years and then suddenly disappeared without a clear explanation.
Buyers should be cautious if:
- The car failed with major defects shortly before being listed for sale
- Long-standing advisories vanish in a single MOT test
- The MOT was carried out very close to the sale date
These patterns often suggest short-term repairs rather than consistent maintenance. Always compare the latest MOT result with older records to see whether defects were genuinely resolved or simply masked to achieve a pass.
Smart buyers don’t rely on the latest MOT result alone. Combining an MOT check with a car history check reveals patterns of ownership, and usage that may indicate hidden issues, for just £19.99. If doubts persist, an independent inspection is strongly recommended.
How MOT history reveals long-term maintenance habits
One of the most overlooked benefits of an MOT check is its ability to tell a story over time. A single failure isn’t always concerning, but repeated failures in the same systems often are.
For example:
- Repeated suspension advisories may suggest ongoing neglect
- Annual tyre failures can indicate aggressive driving or poor alignment
- Recurring emissions issues may point to engine or exhaust problems
A well-maintained car typically shows a clean pattern: occasional minor advisories, promptly resolved, and few major failures. In contrast, a vehicle with a history of major defects followed by minimal repair notes can signal deeper issues.
Buyers should always check whether major failures disappear in subsequent MOTs or simply change category, which could suggest temporary or low-quality repairs.
How can an MOT check strengthen your price negotiation?
Not every major MOT fail means you should abandon a purchase but it should always change how you approach the deal.
If a car recently failed and passed after repairs:
- Ask for invoices or evidence of professional work
- Get an independent inspection if the fault was structural or safety-related
- Use repair costs to negotiate a lower price
If the MOT check shows multiple major failures across several years, negotiation may not be enough. These vehicles often become money pits, especially once warranty coverage ends.
Ultimately, an MOT check empowers buyers to make decisions based on facts rather than seller assurances. It shifts the balance of power, helping you avoid unsafe vehicles and over-priced cars with hidden problems.
Final Thoughts
An MOT pass alone does not guarantee a good car. Understanding the difference between major and minor MOT fails is what separates informed buyers from those who rely on luck.
Minor defects are often manageable and expected. Major failures especially repeated or safety-critical ones should prompt serious caution or an immediate walk-away.
Before buying any used vehicle, always perform a full MOT check and review its history carefully. It’s one of the simplest steps you can take to protect your money, your safety, and your peace of mind.
For more, visit Pure Magazine